Can Cerebral Palsy Be Caused by a Doctor's Mistake? | Honolulu, HI

Can Cerebral Palsy Be Caused by a Doctor’s Mistake in Hawaii?

Few moments hit a parent harder than being told their newborn has cerebral palsy. The questions come fast and they don’t stop: Why did this happen? Could it have been prevented? Did someone make a mistake? Those aren’t just emotional questions. In Hawaii, they are legal ones, and the answers can shape your child’s entire future.

The short answer is yes, cerebral palsy can be caused by a doctor’s mistake. And when it is, Hawaii law gives your family the right to pursue compensation. At SRB Hawaii Law, we represent families on Oahu, Maui, the Big Island, Kauai, and every island in between. Here is what you need to know.

What Is Cerebral Palsy, and How Does It Happen?

Cerebral palsy (CP) is not a single disease. It is a group of neurological conditions that affect movement, muscle tone, and coordination. The damage that causes CP typically happens to a baby’s developing brain before, during, or shortly after birth. Because brain cells harmed during this window do not regenerate, CP is a permanent condition. Depending on which area of the brain was affected and how severely, a child might experience anything from mild coordination challenges to profound physical and cognitive disability.

Some cases of CP result from causes no one could have prevented, including genetic factors, very premature birth, or infections that arise despite appropriate medical care. However, a significant number of cases are associated with preventable medical complications or failures in care. When that is the case, the condition may be considered a birth injury caused by medical negligence, if it can be proven that the provider failed to meet the applicable standard of care and that failure caused the injury.

What Medical Mistakes Can Cause Cerebral Palsy?

The most common pathway from medical error to cerebral palsy involves oxygen deprivation. A newborn’s brain is highly sensitive to changes in oxygen supply. Even brief interruptions in oxygen flow can cause brain injury that may result in CP. The medical term for this type of injury is hypoxic-ischemic encephalopathy, or HIE. In some cases, HIE is preventable with timely recognition and appropriate intervention during labor, delivery, or the immediate newborn period.

Medical complications that may contribute to cerebral palsy when not properly identified or treated include:

  • Failure to monitor fetal heart rate. Electronic fetal monitoring is used to detect signs of fetal distress. When abnormal readings are missed or not acted on in a timely manner, opportunities for intervention may be lost.
  • Delayed or failed cesarean section. When fetal distress is present or labor is not progressing safely, a timely C-section may be necessary to prevent oxygen deprivation and brain injury. Delays in performing a medically indicated cesarean section can increase the risk of harm.
  • Improper use of forceps or vacuum extractors. These instruments must be used with care and only when appropriate. Improper use can contribute to trauma, bleeding, or reduced oxygen supply to the baby, which may result in neurological injury.
  • Failure to diagnose or treat maternal infections. Certain infections, such as Group B Streptococcus, can be transmitted to the baby during delivery and may lead to serious complications, including brain injury, if not properly managed.
  • Failure to address severe newborn jaundice. When jaundice is not properly monitored and treated, bilirubin levels can rise to dangerous levels. This condition, known as kernicterus, can cause brain damage that may result in a form of cerebral palsy.
  • Delayed response to a baby’s breathing difficulties. A newborn who is not breathing adequately requires immediate intervention. Delays in resuscitation or oxygen support can increase the risk of permanent brain injury.
  • Mismanagement of umbilical cord complications. Conditions such as cord prolapse or cord compression can reduce or cut off oxygen supply to the baby. These situations require immediate medical intervention to prevent potential brain injury.

How Do You Know If Negligence Was Involved?

This is not a question most families can answer on their own, and that is not a failing on their part. Medicine is genuinely complex, and determining whether a specific outcome resulted from a preventable error requires careful medical review and legal analysis of the standard of care.

That said, there are patterns worth paying attention to. Did labor last significantly longer than expected without clear medical explanation? Was there a sudden change in your baby’s condition that appeared unexpected or difficult for the staff to explain? Did your baby require emergency resuscitation at birth? Was your child admitted to the NICU for seizures, oxygen deprivation, or breathing problems shortly after delivery? Did anyone on the care team appear rushed, inattentive, or dismissive of concerns raised during labor or delivery?

None of these factors alone proves that negligence occurred. However, these are the types of facts that, when reviewed alongside medical records and evaluated by a qualified physician familiar with the applicable standard of care, may help determine whether a preventable error occurred.

What Does Hawaii Law Require to Bring a Case?

Hawaii has a specific legal process for medical malpractice claims, and every family considering one should understand how it works. 

The Medical Inquiry and Conciliation Panel (MICP)

In most Hawaii medical malpractice cases, a claim must first be submitted to the Medical Inquiry and Conciliation Panel before a lawsuit can proceed in court. This requirement is established under HRS § 671-12. The panel itself, defined under HRS § 671-11, consists of one attorney who serves as chair and one physician. The process is designed to be non-adversarial. After the inquiry is filed and the named providers respond, the panel conducts an informal conciliation proceeding where information is reviewed and discussed. The goal is resolution rather than litigation, though if the matter is not resolved, the claimant may proceed with filing a lawsuit in court. 

The filing fee for the party initiating the inquiry is $450, along with a separate non-refundable $50 processing fee. Each named health care provider is also assessed a $450 filing fee. Fee waivers may be available under HRS § 671-11.5 for individuals who qualify based on financial hardship.

Along with the inquiry, a certificate of consultation must be filed under HRS § 671-12.5. This requires consultation with at least one licensed physician who is knowledgeable in the relevant or related specialty, and an affirmation that there is a reasonable and meritorious basis for the claim. 

The Statute of Limitations

Time matters greatly in these cases. Under HRS § 657-7.3, medical malpractice claims in Hawaii must generally be filed within two years of when the injury was discovered or reasonably should have been discovered. There is also a six-year statute of repose from the date of the alleged negligent act, regardless of discovery. In limited circumstances, the repose period may be tolled where there is fraudulent concealment or intentional nondisclosure of the injury by a health care provider.

For minors, Hawaii law does not create a separate fixed extension such as a “until age ten” rule for medical malpractice claims. Instead, general tolling principles may apply depending on the circumstances, and the statute of repose under HRS § 657-7.3 remains an important limitation in most cases. Because these rules are fact-specific and complex, the timing analysis in pediatric injury cases often depends on when the injury was or reasonably could have been discovered.

Additional tolling may apply in cases involving fraudulent concealment, gross negligence, or other conduct that prevented the timely filing of a claim.

What Compensation Can a Hawaii Family Recover?

When medical negligence is responsible for a child’s cerebral palsy, the financial impact over a lifetime can be substantial. A successful claim may provide compensation for past and future medical expenses, long-term care and in-home assistance, adaptive housing and vehicle modifications, the child’s loss of future earning capacity, and educational and therapeutic support services. 

Under HRS § 663-8.7, Hawaii generally limits recovery for noneconomic damages in medical malpractice cases to $375,000. This cap applies to non-economic losses arising from the injury, including pain and suffering, emotional distress, and loss of enjoyment of life. It does not apply to economic damages such as medical costs, long-term care expenses, or lost earning capacity. It also does not limit recovery for separate categories of damages where otherwise permitted by law, such as certain derivative claims when applicable. In a case involving a child who will require lifelong care, economic damages often form the most significant portion of recovery. 

Key Takeaways

  • Cerebral palsy can result from preventable medical complications during labor, delivery, or the newborn period, often involving oxygen deprivation to the baby’s brain. Determining whether negligence played a role requires medical and legal analysis of the standard of care and causation.
  • Hawaii law generally requires medical malpractice claims to be submitted to the Medical Inquiry and Conciliation Panel under HRS § 671-11 and § 671-12 before a lawsuit can proceed in court.
  • A certificate of consultation from a licensed physician who is knowledgeable in the relevant or related specialty is required under HRS § 671-12.5.
  • The general statute of limitations under HRS § 657-7.3 is two years from discovery of the injury, with a six-year statute of repose from the date of the alleged negligent act. Limited tolling may apply in specific circumstances, including fraudulent concealment or delayed discovery, and timing rules in cases involving minors are fact-specific and governed by both tolling principles and the statute of repose.
  • Hawaii’s $375,000 cap under HRS § 663-8.7 applies to total noneconomic damages in medical malpractice cases, including pain and suffering, emotional distress, and loss of enjoyment of life. Economic damages are not subject to this cap.
  • Acting promptly helps preserve evidence, maintain access to medical records, and protect all available legal options.

Frequently Asked Questions

Q: My child was just diagnosed with CP, but the birth was two years ago. Have I missed the deadline?

A: Not necessarily. Under Hawaii law, medical malpractice claims are generally subject to a two-year discovery rule and a six-year statute of repose under HRS § 657-7.3. This means the clock often depends on when the injury and its possible connection to medical care were discovered or reasonably should have been discovered. In many cerebral palsy cases, that connection is not immediately clear. The timing rules can be complex, especially in cases involving children, so it is important to have the facts reviewed as soon as possible. 

Q: What if I signed paperwork at the hospital after delivery? Does that waive my rights?

A: Standard hospital consent forms and discharge paperwork do not waive your right to bring a medical malpractice claim. A valid waiver of legal rights generally requires a specific and informed release agreement that clearly addresses known claims, and even those releases may be subject to legal challenge depending on the circumstances. You should not assume that routine paperwork affects your ability to pursue a claim. 

Q: Does my child need to be severely affected for me to have a case?

A: No. The severity of the injury does not determine whether a claim exists. A valid medical malpractice case depends on whether a health care provider failed to meet the applicable standard of care and whether that failure caused the injury. Severity primarily affects the value of the claim, not whether it can be brought. 

Q: Can I sue the hospital, or only the individual doctor?

A: Both may be possible. In Hawaii, hospitals can be held liable for negligence committed by their employees, including nurses, residents, and employed physicians. When care is provided by independent contractors, liability depends on the specific relationship and circumstances, but hospitals may still be responsible in certain situations under Hawaii law. 

Q: What if the MICP does not find in my favor?

A: The Medical Inquiry and Conciliation Panel’s findings are not binding on either party. If the panel does not find actionable negligence, you may still file a lawsuit in court. The MICP process is a required preliminary step in most medical malpractice cases, but it does not determine the final outcome of a claim.

Contact SRB Hawaii Law

If your child has been diagnosed with cerebral palsy and you are wondering whether a medical mistake played a role, do not let those questions sit unanswered. Every day that passes is a day closer to legal deadlines, and it is a day longer that your family goes without the information it needs to make sound decisions.

At SRB Hawaii Law, attorney Stephen Brzezinski has built his practice around fighting for families who have been harmed by medical negligence across all of the Hawaiian Islands. These cases are handled on a contingency fee basis, meaning you pay nothing unless we recover compensation for your family. 

Contact us today to schedule your free consultation. We will listen carefully, review the facts of your situation, and tell you where you stand. Your child’s future is worth that conversation.

Birth Injury Attorney

GET THE HELP YOU DESERVE. CONTACT US TODAY!

Sidebar

By submitting your phone number and email on Srbhawaiilaw.com, you consent to being contacted by SRB Hawaii Law, for assistance with your legal needs. Your information will be kept confidential in accordance with our Privacy Policy

Birth Injury Attorney

Get HELP TODAY with our Hawaii Birth Injury Medical Malpractice Attorneys

Birth Injury Attorney